What a mess. I trust, as a good traveler, you’re following the news feed from Detroit after the near-miss with the Nigerian wannabe-terrorist aboard the Northwest flight from Amsterdam on Christmas Day. Hmm.
First, we have a directive from the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) which ramped up regulations regarding passenger movement around the plane in the final hour of flight, access to carry-on bags and additional personal searches and bag checks.
To review, here’s how the TSA initially reacted. These initial reactions, by the way, applied primarily to international flights in-bound to the U.S. Although there were sporadic reports of more restrictive policies in place for domestic flights, the international flights are the ones most affected:
a. Passengers must remain seated during the final hour before landing.
b. Passengers may not access their carry-on luggage during the final hour before landing.
c. Passengers may not have anything in their laps–and must surrender all pillows and blankets.
d. Passengers will be subject to thorough physical pat-downs at the boarding gate, with emphasis on the upper legs and torso.
e. Passengers will be subject to secondary physical searches of their carry-on luggage before boarding, in addition to the initial security screening at check-in.
f. Travelers from Canada to the U.S. are limited to one small carry-on only.
Note: Alaska Airlines and Horizon Air indicated they would waive some fees for baggage. Specifically, if a bag originally was to be carried on board, Alaska/Horizon would waive the charge in order to check the bag and accommodate this new security directive.
Naturally, the new directives were getting heavy push-back from travelers and security experts alike. Why is 60 minutes the “magic” number after which everyone must put everything up and sit with their hands in full view of the flight attendant?








Oh, for crying out loud! If this weren’t such a serious subject, I would be lying on the ground rolling with laughter, sure that this was a 3-stooges movie. I do my fair share of traveling and every airport is different, but if security personnal would spend less time being concerned with my carried-on toothpaste and more time screening someone who fits the profile of those who have been wreaking havoc in our world (yes, I think it’s O.K. to profile here, people! – Hellllllloooooooo!), then maybe the most recent jerk never would have made it past the “watch” list and two passes through airport security. Sheesh. TSA, make some rules that make sense for Pete’s sake. Glad they lifted the 1-hour rule; that was about one of the dumbest I’ve seen; I wondered if there was some kind of Muslim law that forbade blowing up planes except during the last hour of flight. . .give me a break. . .
Keep up the good work, Scott. I enjoy your articles-I’m a legal secretary and recall the early years when you used to work at US Travel and delivered our company airline tickets right to our door. Yep, that was awhile ago. . .
You wouldn’t be thinking this SOOOOO ridiculous if you’ve ever flown into Washington,DC since 9/11. You can not so much as stand up at your seat in the last hour before landing in DC, or get arrested when the plane lands. NO ONE questions the rule on those flights.
Mm-hmm. I have flown in/out of Reagan since then. And, indeed, I was prepared to pee in the barf bag. OMG.
I have traveled since 9/11 in and out of DC every year and haven’t had the restrictions noted above. Must be airline dependent. Today the “president” called it for what it is, an Intelligence problem. But as the man said in the movie – ” why shoot the pig just because he saw the fox enter the hen house?” We are shooting the pig when we let them off the hook and make Americans give freedoms to accomadate terrorists!